We have received the following from Richard T:
Pump Hill
Many will recall the pretty garden maintained by Dorothy Littlewood, in spring a beautiful dappled glade of bluebells, daffodils and narcissus.
The land, known as Pump Hill, and making up part of The Square, was given to the village about ten years ago. I don’t think I was alone in believing that the reason for the acquisition was to preserve a parcel which is at the heart of the village. It was my sense that the parish council was to own it on behalf of the village in a fiduciary capacity and thus inalienable. I found that reassuring. No one ever thought for one moment that the property might be sold by a later parish council with different values so this was never formally put down in writing and enshrined in any trust document.
But now the parish council IS minded to sell and is seeking a buyer as an option. While there has been some activity on this blog in the past, the parish council has not sought the views of the village as a whole nor has it explained why it wants to sell and the options it has explored.
I, for one, thought the land had been acquired and “saved” for the benefit of our community as a whole – a kind of unwritten trust -and not to be traded in the manner of a property portfolio.
I would have thought there were a number of options for the parish council to explore, such as:
* allowing the site to become a wildlife sanctuary encouraging birds, butterflies, beetles etc. (The site is next to the lower of the two school playgrounds). This surely would not cost a huge sum to manage.
* allotments, a previous use in living memory
* letting at a peppercorn rent as a garden and open space
* letting at a peppercorn rent as an extension to the lower adjoining school playground
A proposed sale has already attracted interest which suggests people might like to use Pump Hill, presumably as a garden.
Pump Hill is a visually valuable and sensitive part of the village amenity in the heart of the conservation area – the smells in spring, the approach to the area arched by trees and blossoms, the framing of Parwich Hill which makes a breathtaking picture behind, a characteristic of the the southern White Peak.
Pump Hill is part of the rich and unique tapestry of Parwich which is one of the reasons why we want to live here. I am sure others feel the same but I may be wrong.
In my view, there should be wide consultation with our community which may, in the process, throw up other ideas for its use. It should be unhurried and considered – certainly not hasty. Common sense would suggest a public meeting. (That would enable a significant minority, who do not “do” the Internet to hear the arguments first hand and make valuable contributions to the discussions,. They are from a largely different generation.)
We should not forget that the parish council has extensive property interests. A sale could establish a dangerous precedent that the parish council is open to offers, however small a site.
If it does come to a disposal, and to reflect what I believe was our understanding of a “fiduciary” duty to preserve this “green lung” for the village, a number of options may present themselves as alternatives while maintaining the principle of keeping this picturesque property for the public good.
These might include donating the site to the National Trust, The Woodland Trust, the Derbyshire
Wildlife Trust (with an agreed management scheme?) or even the Peak District National Park Authority. I do not know if the Friends of the Peak District assume property ownerships.
But at the end of the day, the best owners might well be the parish council. So let your councillor know.
Richard T



Well said Richard T. I believe that piece of land could be put to good use for the village, my original thought was that of a car park as the village hall has very few car park spaces, but I also like the thought of the land being used by the school in some way, everyone would like to see the youngsters being taught the finer points of gardening and country living.
I have to agree. That was a very nicely put, reasonable presentation. I particularly liked the idea of the area being used as a nature area/reserve which I am sure the school (and our children) could hugely benefit from, and take a major part in maintaining. This is an idea that I would be honoured to be a part of. Once it is sold, that is it, and quite possibly, an opportunity missed.
This land MUST stay in the ownership of a the village.The Parish Council purchased it when it was auctioned by Bagshaws to keep it within the control of the Parish as an asset for the village to enjoy not as an item for sale without consultationDavid & Janice Wigley
There appear to be some strong feelings over plans by the Parish Council to sell Pump Hill and some members of the public attended last night’s meeting to make their views known.
The council discussed Pump Hill again at the meeting but it was a CONFIDENTIAL item so the public were regrettably EXCLUDED from the deliberations.
We do not know who sad what nor do we know what was agreed.
As a matter of urgency, will the parish council kindly issue a statement on Parwich.org and on notice boards at the earliest opportunity stating where they are in relation to a disposal .
Did councillors, who sign up to a code of openness and transparency, consider a public meeting with the community and, if so, what was their decision and why?